TV Shows Like One of Us Is Lying
If you like One of Us Is Lying, here are 10 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Peacock · Drama · One of Us Is Lying is cancelled
One of Us Is Lying hooks you immediately with its central mystery: a death in detention that could implicate any of five teenagers. What makes the show work is not just the whodunit, but the way it treats each suspect as fully realized—kids with separate secrets, separate pressures, separate reasons to want their peers dead or alive. It's a locked-room mystery, yes, but also a character study. Fans of the show tend to want more of that combination: mysteries that don't feel like pure plot mechanics, but rather stories where solving the case means understanding people.
The best shows like One of Us Is Lying
1. Pretty Little Liars
Pretty Little Liars delivers the same blend of high school drama and escalating mystery, with a group of friends bound together by dangerous secrets and targeted by someone who knows all their vulnerabilities. Like One of Us Is Lying, it's a mystery where everyone has motive and means, and where the social dynamics of the school matter as much as the investigation itself.
Stream on Hulu, HBO Max Amazon Channel, HBO Max
Ended0%
2. A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
This show centers a teenager determined to crack a murder case that official investigators have closed, building tension through amateur detective work and the discovery that nothing is as straightforward as it seems. If you loved the way One of Us Is Lying forces each character into the spotlight as suspect and sympathetic figure, you'll respond to how this show gradually expands your understanding of who Andie Bell was and why she died.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Likely Renewed72%
3. School Spirits
School Spirits traps its protagonist in her own murder investigation, forcing her to uncover not just who killed her, but why everyone around her has reasons to lie about what happened. It shares One of Us Is Lying's focus on high school dynamics and LGBT characters, and it builds the same mounting dread as more secrets surface with each discovery.
Stream on fuboTV, Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential, Paramount Plus Apple TV Channel
Likely Renewed62%
4. Tell Me Lies
Tell Me Lies mirrors the way One of Us Is Lying reveals character through secrecy, following an addictive and destructive relationship that ripples outward to damage everyone it touches. It's a mystery told in fragments—pieces of truth and lies scattered across time—that only cohere when you understand what each person stood to lose.
Stream on Hulu
Ended0%
5. The Crowded Room
The Crowded Room layers mystery with psychology, asking an investigator to understand the mind of a young man at the center of a shocking crime. Like One of Us Is Lying, it's invested in the interior lives of its characters and how trauma, circumstance, and identity collide to create the conditions for violence.
Stream on Apple TV, Apple TV Amazon Channel
Ended0%
More on shows like One of Us Is Lying
That's what connects this list of recommendations. These shows all share that same architecture: a mystery at the center, and multiple suspects or viewpoints that gradually reveal why each person matters. They're invested in teenage life and its specific agonies—social hierarchies, forbidden attraction, the weight of secrets—but they're also drawn to the structure of the mystery itself, the pleasure of gathering clues and revising your suspicions. Some are darker than others. Some spend more time on the investigation, others on the fallout.
Pretty Little Liars pioneered much of this territory, following four girls harassed by an anonymous tormentor with connections to their past. A Good Girl's Guide to Murder puts the investigation in a teenager's hands as she pursues a case everyone else thinks is closed. School Spirits traps its protagonist in a literal mystery, investigating her own death while stuck between worlds. Tell Me Lies and The Crowded Room veer slightly differently—they're less about solving a specific crime and more about untangling the web of lies that connects people together—but they share that same fascination with how secrets compound and reshape lives. Each show understands that in mystery stories about young people, the case and the character study are inseparable.
More shows like One of Us Is Lying
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like One of Us Is Lying?
- Pretty Little Liars is the most popular show similar to One of Us Is Lying in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like One of Us Is Lying still on the air?
- Of the 10 shows similar to One of Us Is Lying listed here, 1 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like One of Us Is Lying?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.