TV Shows Like The Summer I Turned Pretty
If you like The Summer I Turned Pretty, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Prime Video · Drama · The Summer I Turned Pretty is ended
The Summer I Turned Pretty works because it is honest about the specific ache of being on the edge of adulthood. Belly's summers at Cousins Beach are fixed points, familiar and safe, and the show understands that the moment a place you love starts to feel different, you have already changed. The love triangle at the center of it gives the series its tension, but what keeps people watching is the texture around it: the family dynamics, the beach house as a character in itself, the way grief and joy sit next to each other without the show forcing either one to win. It is romantic without being naive, and that balance is hard to get right.
The best shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty
1. The Vampire Diaries
If the love triangle between Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah is what hooked you, The Vampire Diaries runs on the same engine. Two brothers, one girl, and a long history between all of them gives the show its central tension, and it commits to that triangle with the same seriousness that The Summer I Turned Pretty does. The supernatural elements are a big departure, but the emotional logic underneath is familiar: love that is complicated by loyalty, history, and the feeling that a choice between two people is also a choice about who you want to be.
Stream on HBO Max, HBO Max Amazon Channel, Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Ended0%
2. One Tree Hill
One Tree Hill is about two half-brothers whose rivalry is really about a father who chose one of them and not the other, and it has the same quality The Summer I Turned Pretty has of locating big emotional truths inside what looks like ordinary youth drama. The relationships here are layered and the show is not afraid of grief or of joy. If you liked the way Cousins Beach felt like a world with its own rules and history, Tree Hill has that same sense of a place that holds people's whole lives inside it.
Stream on Hulu, HBO Max, HBO Max Amazon Channel
Ended0%
3. This Is Us
This Is Us is about families and the way the past keeps shaping the present, which puts it in the same territory as The Summer I Turned Pretty even though the characters are older. The show moves between timelines with a lot of care, and it earns its emotional moments rather than just reaching for them. Fans of The Summer I Turned Pretty who responded to the grief running underneath the romance will find a lot to hold onto here.
Stream on Hulu, YouTube TV, NBC
Ended0%
4. Virgin River
Virgin River shares The Summer I Turned Pretty's interest in a specific place as the container for romantic and emotional possibility, just with an adult protagonist starting over rather than a teenager coming into her own. The tone is warm and the romance is central, and the show builds a small community around its main relationship in a way that feels lived-in. It is a gentler watch, but it has the same sentimental honesty that makes The Summer I Turned Pretty easy to return to.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Renewed100%
5. My Life with the Walter Boys
This is the most direct match for fans of The Summer I Turned Pretty: a teenage girl in an unfamiliar environment, a large family she has to figure out how to belong to, and a love triangle that is genuinely hard to resolve because both options matter. The show is based on a young adult novel, shares the same romantic sensibility, and takes its protagonist's internal life seriously. If you finished The Summer I Turned Pretty and wanted more of exactly that, this is the place to start.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Renewed100%
More on shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty
Fans of this show tend to want a few specific things when they look for something to watch next. They want emotional stakes that feel personal, not just plot-level drama. They want relationships that are complicated and earned, and they want a setting or a community that feels like somewhere real. They are not necessarily looking for teen drama as a genre category, but they are looking for the feeling the show produces: the sense that something is ending and beginning at the same time.
The recommendations here cover that territory from a few different angles. The Vampire Diaries keeps the love-triangle structure and the intensity of first love, just with considerably higher supernatural stakes. One Tree Hill is probably the closest in spirit, a show about small-town youth, brothers in conflict, and the weight of family history, told with a lot of heart. This Is Us goes older and sadder, but it has the same investment in how families shape people across time. Virgin River trades the beach house for a small California town and leans into romance and community in a way that shares the show's warmer register. My Life with the Walter Boys is the most direct match in terms of audience and setup: a teenager, a new environment, and a love triangle that asks her to figure out who she actually is.
None of these are identical to The Summer I Turned Pretty, and they should not be. What they share is the conviction that relationships, especially the messy and uncertain ones, are worth taking seriously.
More shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like The Summer I Turned Pretty?
- The Vampire Diaries is the most popular show similar to The Summer I Turned Pretty in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to The Summer I Turned Pretty listed here, 2 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.