TV Shows Like Poker Face
If you like Poker Face, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Peacock · Crime · Poker Face is cancelled
Charlie Cale's gift is both a blessing and a curse, one that makes her incapable of walking away from a crime that needs solving. Poker Face mines the oddness of this premise hard, turning what could be a gimmick (woman who detects lies) into something darker and more resonant. The show works because it embraces the episodic road trip format, letting each new town and cast of characters feel like its own world. Charlie moves through American spaces with the world-weariness of someone who has seen how quickly ordinary people turn to violence and deception. She is not a brilliant detective who collects clues like puzzle pieces. She is someone cursed with the ability to see through lies, which means she has to act.
The best shows like Poker Face
1. Criminal Minds
Criminal Minds shares Poker Face's fascination with how crime reveals character, though it approaches investigation through psychology and profiling rather than lie detection. The show offers the same satisfaction of watching smart people unravel violent crimes, with episodic cases and a core team you grow to trust.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential
Renewed100%
2. The Blacklist
Like Poker Face, The Blacklist centers on an outsider with unique insight helping law enforcement agents solve cases, though with higher stakes and a central mystery that keeps building. Both shows thrive on the tension between a protagonist who sees the world differently and the official system trying to contain them.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Ended0%
3. True Detective
True Detective matches Poker Face's somber tone and interest in how crimes damage everyone involved, including the investigators. The show examines moral corruption and institutional failure through the lens of detectives pushed beyond their limits, with a nonlinear structure that keeps you guessing.
Stream on HBO Max Amazon Channel, YouTube TV, TNT, HBO Max
Likely Renewed72%
4. Only Murders in the Building
Only Murders in the Building takes mystery seriously while finding unexpected humor in obsession and amateurism, much like Poker Face does with Charlie's predicament. Three ordinary people stumbling toward truth mirrors the resourcefulness of someone who solves crimes not because they are qualified but because they cannot look away.
Stream on Disney Plus, Hulu
Renewed100%
5. The Sinner
The Sinner uses the anthology format to explore crimes that unsettle and disturb, with a detective protagonist haunted by what he uncovers, echoing the somber, desperate mood of Poker Face. Each case digs beneath the surface of small-town American life to find psychological terror and moral ambiguity.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Ended0%
More on shows like Poker Face
Fans of Poker Face tend to love mystery for its own sake, that feeling of being kept off balance as the truth emerges. They like stories where the protagonist is resourceful and determined rather than procedurally flawless. The somber, desperate tone appeals to them more than the cozy mystery or lighthearted detective format. They want crimes that feel real and messy, not neat. And they are drawn to protagonists who exist somewhat outside the law or institutional power, who solve crimes because they have to, not because it is their job.
The recommendations here approach mystery and crime investigation from different angles. Criminal Minds and The Blacklist are larger procedural ensembles where expertise and access to institutional power matter more than a single person's intuition. True Detective offers something closer in spirit to Poker Face, a darker investigation into crimes and the people haunted by them. Only Murders in the Building brings the mystery home to a fixed location and finds dark comedy in obsession. The Sinner, like Poker Face, uses each case to dig into the psychology of crime and the detective trying to make sense of senseless violence.
More shows like Poker Face
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Poker Face?
- Criminal Minds is the most popular show similar to Poker Face in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Poker Face still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to Poker Face listed here, 2 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Poker Face?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.