TV Shows Like Midnight Mass
If you like Midnight Mass, here are 11 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Netflix · Mystery · Midnight Mass is ended
Midnight Mass finds its power in the space between faith and doubt. A charismatic priest arrives in a dying fishing village with miracles in tow, and the town, desperate and grieving and looking for any reason to believe, embraces him. But Mike Flanagan's series knows that miracles cast long shadows. The show examines what happens when religion becomes intoxicating, when the promise of salvation masks something older and more sinister beneath the surface. It's a story about addiction in its broadest form: the hunger to transcend pain, to find meaning, to be saved.
The best shows like Midnight Mass
1. FROM
Like Midnight Mass, From creates a trap from which there is no escape, forcing its characters to confront both external horror and the ways they turn on each other under pressure. The show's folk horror atmosphere and the terror of the surrounding forest echo the closing act's shift from miracle to nightmare.
Stream on fuboTV, MGM+ Amazon Channel, MGM Plus Roku Premium Channel, MGM Plus
Likely Renewed72%
2. Twin Peaks
Twin Peaks pioneered the small-town mystery with supernatural depths that Midnight Mass builds on directly. Both shows understand that the real horror often lives in the community itself, and that solving the mystery means understanding how badly people want to believe in something larger than themselves.
Stream on Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, MUBI
Ended0%
3. Dark Winds
This series shares Midnight Mass's willingness to take spiritual beliefs seriously as motivating forces in a murder investigation. The 1970s Southwest setting and the weight given to Navajo beliefs create the same tension between rational investigation and something that defies explanation.
Stream on Netflix, Philo, AMC Plus Apple TV Channel , AMC+ Amazon Channel
Renewed100%
4. Evil
Evil is built on the same central conflict as Midnight Mass: the clash between skepticism and supernatural possibility, between what can be explained and what cannot. The Catholic priest, the investigation into supposed miracles, and the question of whether something genuinely demonic is at work all speak directly to themes Midnight Mass explores.
Stream on Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential, Paramount Plus Apple TV Channel , Paramount+ Amazon Channel
Ended0%
5. The Sinner
The Sinner shares Midnight Mass's interest in crimes rooted in desperation and the ways trauma shapes belief. Its haunted detective and twisted moral landscape echo the show's examination of how damaged people try to transcend their pain, sometimes through destructive means.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Ended0%
More on shows like Midnight Mass
That core appeal draws fans toward mysteries that operate on multiple levels at once. They want shows that take their central premise seriously but refuse simple explanations. They're comfortable with slow builds, with small-town claustrophobia, with characters wrestling against forces both internal and external. They appreciate work that treats religion and spirituality not as background decoration but as something people genuinely stake their lives on. And they're drawn to horror that emerges from character and consequence rather than jump scares.
The recommendations here share that DNA. From traps its characters in a town where the rules don't work and the forest hunts them. Twin Peaks planted the template for this kind of storytelling: a small town with terrible secrets, law enforcement trying to impose order on chaos, a mystery that runs deeper than any single crime. Dark Winds brings that same spiritual weight to the 1970s Southwest, asking Navajo officers to confront both an investigation and their own beliefs. Evil mirrors Midnight Mass's central tension almost exactly, watching skeptics and believers try to determine what's really supernatural and what's human darkness. The Sinner, meanwhile, anchors its crimes in memory and trauma, the way Midnight Mass anchors its mysteries in what people desperately want to believe.
More shows like Midnight Mass
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Midnight Mass?
- FROM is the most popular show similar to Midnight Mass in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Midnight Mass still on the air?
- Of the 11 shows similar to Midnight Mass listed here, 1 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Midnight Mass?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.