TV Shows Like Midnight Mass
If you like Midnight Mass, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Netflix · Mystery · Midnight Mass is ended
Midnight Mass works because it trusts both the spiritual and the skeptical sides of its central question. A young priest arrives in a small, struggling community and miracles begin to happen, but the show never lets you settle into simple faith or simple doubt. Instead it assembles a complete world of characters, each wrestling privately with belief and desperation, and then it reveals that the mystery was always less important than what each person wanted it to be. The appeal of the show lies in this balance: it has genuine scares and supernatural atmospherics, but it uses them to explore how people cling to meaning in the face of decay and mortality.
The best shows like Midnight Mass
1. Twin Peaks
Twin Peaks created the template for intelligent mystery television that uses a small town and an impossible crime to explore the hidden darkness in ordinary people. Like Midnight Mass, it's driven by atmosphere and character more than plot mechanics, and it treats the supernatural elements as genuine expressions of internal turmoil.
Stream on Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, MUBI
Ended0%
2. Evil
Evil directly tackles the tension between faith and skepticism that runs through Midnight Mass by putting a priest and a skeptical psychologist on the same investigative team. It shares the same commitment to asking hard questions about belief while treating the supernatural as genuinely unsettling and ambiguous.
Stream on Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential, Paramount Plus Apple TV Channel , Paramount+ Amazon Channel
Ended0%
3. The Sinner
The Sinner strips away the supernatural elements but keeps the core appeal: a mystery that's really about broken people in a small community, and a detective searching for answers while confronting his own damage. It has the same slow, character-driven pacing and the same interest in psychology over action.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Ended0%
4. Sleepy Hollow
Sleepy Hollow uses mythology and time-travel spectacle to explore themes of faith, legacy, and the weight of history that echo through Midnight Mass. It treats the supernatural not as mere decoration but as a reflection of the characters' internal conflicts and their struggle to belong.
Stream on Hulu
Cancelled0%
5. Dark Winds
Dark Winds grounds its mystery in a specific community and a specific spiritual tradition, much like Midnight Mass roots itself in Catholicism and island life. It shares the same interest in how belief systems clash with rational investigation, and how trauma and tradition shape how people interpret the world around them.
Stream on Netflix, AMC Plus Apple TV Channel , AMC+ Amazon Channel, AMC+ Roku Premium Channel
Renewed100%
More on shows like Midnight Mass
Fans of Midnight Mass tend to want that same combination of mystery and character depth. They like shows that ask difficult questions rather than provide easy answers, and they want those questions grounded in specific communities and specific people. They appreciate slowburn storytelling that lets tension build through dialogue and relationship, not just plot. And crucially, they want the supernatural or mysterious elements to carry psychological weight, to expose something true about desire and fear and belief.
The recommendations here all share that sensibility. Twin Peaks is the godfather of this entire strain of television, a show that treats a small-town mystery as the doorway into something far stranger and more personal. Evil examines the gap between faith and reason by making both characters compelling, much like Midnight Mass does. The Sinner and Dark Winds are grittier detective stories, but they share the same commitment to the interior lives of damaged people trying to make sense of violence and trauma. Sleepy Hollow leans more heavily into spectacle and action, but it still understands that the real story is about people pulled into mysteries larger than themselves. These shows all believe that a good mystery is ultimately a way to study character under pressure.
More shows like Midnight Mass
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Midnight Mass?
- Twin Peaks is the most popular show similar to Midnight Mass in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Midnight Mass still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to Midnight Mass listed here, 1 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Midnight Mass?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.