TV Shows Like The Secret Circle
If you like The Secret Circle, here are 11 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
The CW · Drama · The Secret Circle is cancelled
The Secret Circle pulled viewers into the intimate terror of discovering you're not alone, that the world has rules you never knew existed, and that your friends are bound to you by ancient forces. It's about the uncanny collision between ordinary high school life and real supernatural danger, where a girl's grief and isolation become the catalyst for unraveling a web of family secrets and dark magic. The show understood that witchcraft works best as a metaphor when it's grounded in real relationships and real stakes.
The best shows like The Secret Circle
1. Once Upon a Time
Like The Secret Circle, Once Upon a Time builds its mythology around hidden truths and the revelation that the ordinary world contains extraordinary secrets. Both shows treat magic as serious business embedded in personal relationships and family history, and both create mystery through the slow uncovering of who people really are.
Stream on Disney Plus, Hulu
Ended0%
2. WandaVision
WandaVision shares The Secret Circle's understanding that magic and power emerge from grief and loss, and that the supernatural can become dangerous when someone is trying to escape pain. Both shows ask difficult questions about what magic costs and what people will do to protect themselves and the ones they love.
Stream on Disney Plus
Ended0%
3. The Magicians
The Magicians follows a group of young people discovering that the fantasy world they thought was fiction is real and threatens everything they thought they knew. Like The Secret Circle, it's about the disorientation of finding yourself part of something larger and more dangerous than you imagined, where friendship and loyalty are constantly tested.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Ended0%
4. A Discovery of Witches
A Discovery of Witches centers a witch protagonist caught in a mystery that unravels generations of hidden knowledge and dangerous secrets. Like The Secret Circle, it treats witchcraft as real and consequential, embedding magic in history, relationships, and the ongoing threat of people who want that power for themselves.
Stream on Netflix, AMC Plus Apple TV Channel , AMC+ Amazon Channel, AMC+ Roku Premium Channel
Ended0%
5. Charmed
Charmed begins exactly where The Secret Circle does, with sisters discovering their magical power after their mother's death, and follows them as they navigate the weight of inherited magic and the dangers that come with it. Both shows understand that witchcraft binds you to people whether you're ready or not.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Cancelled0%
More on shows like The Secret Circle
Fans of The Secret Circle tend to want more than just spell-casting and mystical aesthetics. They're looking for stories where magic is embedded in actual character conflict, where young people face real consequences for their power, and where the supernatural functions as a lens for examining identity, belonging, and inherited trauma. They want ensemble casts where loyalty matters and friendships are tested, and they're willing to follow darker threads: the knowledge that not everyone can be trusted, that magic comes with a price, and that sometimes the real danger comes from within the group itself.
The shows we've gathered here all take that foundation seriously. Once Upon a Time builds an entire world around trapped characters and broken spells, weaving in mystery and revelation the way The Secret Circle did with Cassie's family history. WandaVision strips away the glamour and asks what happens when magical power meets grief and creates something dangerous. The Magicians takes the journey from adolescence into magical adulthood and makes it far messier and more consequential than any textbook could suggest. A Discovery of Witches places its witch protagonist at the center of a murder mystery that spans centuries, grounding the fantastical in scholarly intrigue. And Charmed takes the exact premise, sisters discovering their power after their mother's death, and builds from there with the same urgency.
More shows like The Secret Circle
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like The Secret Circle?
- Once Upon a Time is the most popular show similar to The Secret Circle in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like The Secret Circle still on the air?
- Of the 11 shows similar to The Secret Circle listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like The Secret Circle?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.