TV Shows Like Only Murders in the Building
If you like Only Murders in the Building, here are 11 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Hulu · Comedy · Only Murders in the Building is renewed
Only Murders in the Building works because it earns its laughs and its tension at the same time. Three mismatched neighbors, bonded by their love of true crime podcasts, stumble into an actual murder and proceed to investigate with a mix of genuine curiosity, personal baggage, and spectacular incompetence. The show is warm without being soft, funny without undercutting the stakes, and it treats its New York City apartment building as a full character in its own right. That balance, comedy and real mystery woven together rather than alternating awkwardly, is what keeps fans coming back.
The best shows like Only Murders in the Building
1. Poker Face
Poker Face follows Charlie Cale, a woman with an uncanny ability to detect lies, as she drifts from town to town and stumbles into a fresh crime at every stop. Like Only Murders, it pairs a genuinely clever mystery structure with a charismatic central character whose instincts are sharper than her circumstances. The episodic format means each stop feels like its own complete story, and Charlie's wry resilience will feel immediately familiar to fans of Only Murders' core trio.
Stream on Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Cancelled0%
2. Peep Show
Peep Show is not a crime show, but it is one of the funniest studies of an unlikely friendship on television. Mark and Jeremy are as mismatched as any duo in Only Murders, and the show mines their codependence for comedy that is observational, specific, and occasionally painful. If what you love most about Only Murders is watching people who probably should not be friends navigate the world together, Peep Show delivers that in abundance.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, Britbox Apple TV Channel , BritBox
Ended0%
3. Santa Clarita Diet
Santa Clarita Diet shares Only Murders' willingness to treat murder as both a serious problem and a source of dark comedy. The show follows a married couple who find themselves dealing with increasingly grim situations while trying to maintain a completely ordinary suburban life, and the tension between those two registers is where most of the humor lives. If you enjoy Only Murders' ability to make you laugh at something you probably should not be laughing at, this one is worth your time.
Stream on Netflix
Cancelled0%
4. Prey
Prey is a lean, three-part crime thriller about a detective who finds himself accused of the very murder he set out to investigate. It drops the comedy entirely in favor of mounting dread and a tight plot that keeps you questioning who to trust. Fans of Only Murders who are drawn most to its mystery mechanics and its willingness to implicate everyone will find Prey a satisfying, if considerably darker, next watch.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, Peacock Premium, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Ended0%
5. The Afterparty
The Afterparty is probably the closest match to Only Murders in tone and structure: a contained murder mystery, a group of suspects with overlapping and contradictory accounts, and a writers' room that clearly loves the genre it is playing with. The twist here is that each suspect's version of events is told in a different film genre, which gives the show a formal inventiveness that goes well beyond a simple gimmick. If Only Murders is your kind of show, this one will feel like it was made for you.
Stream on Apple TV, Apple TV Amazon Channel
Cancelled0%
More on shows like Only Murders in the Building
People who love Only Murders tend to want a few specific things from their next show: a mystery that actually has a satisfying shape to it, characters whose relationships matter as much as the plot, and a tone that allows humor to live right next to genuine suspense. They are not looking for pure slapstick or procedural grimness. They want a show that trusts them to follow a twisting story while also making them laugh.
The recommendations here cover a good range of that territory. Poker Face leans into the crime-comedy overlap with a road-trip structure and a sharp central character who can never quite walk away from trouble. The Afterparty is probably the closest tonal match, a single-location murder mystery that plays with genre in clever ways. Santa Clarita Diet is darker and weirder but shares that same instinct for finding comedy in situations that really should not be funny. Peep Show is the outlier, a pure character comedy without crime, but fans of the character dynamics in Only Murders will find something to love in its close observation of two deeply flawed people. Prey is the straightest dramatic entry of the bunch, a tightly constructed crime thriller that trades laughs for tension, but rewards the same kind of careful attention to detail that Only Murders demands.
None of these are exact copies of what Only Murders does, which is the point. The best next show for a fan of Only Murders is one that shares its values, not its format.
More shows like Only Murders in the Building
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Only Murders in the Building?
- Poker Face is the most popular show similar to Only Murders in the Building in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Only Murders in the Building still on the air?
- Of the 11 shows similar to Only Murders in the Building listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Only Murders in the Building?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.