TV Shows Like Only Murders in the Building
If you like Only Murders in the Building, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Hulu · Comedy · Only Murders in the Building is renewed
Only Murders in the Building works because it earns its comedy and its mystery in equal measure. The show trusts that you can laugh at a bumbling amateur sleuth and still feel real dread about a killer on the loose. What holds it together is the friendship at its center: three wildly mismatched people who bond over their obsession with true crime and end up living inside one. The podcast framing is clever without being gimmicky, and the New York setting, specifically the Arconia apartment building, does the work of a character in its own right. It's also a show that takes its supporting cast seriously, giving space to characters who might be dismissed elsewhere, including deaf characters and LGBTQ storylines, without making those feel like checkboxes.
The best shows like Only Murders in the Building
1. Poker Face
Charlie Cale is the kind of protagonist Only Murders fans will attach to immediately: funny, resourceful, and stuck in situations she didn't ask for but can't walk away from. The episodic format means a new crime and a new set of characters every week, which keeps things fresh without sacrificing investment in the lead. The tone is a little darker and more solitary than Only Murders, but the blend of solid mystery craft and character-driven warmth is very much the same.
Stream on Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Cancelled0%
2. Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency
If you love the way Only Murders throws an unlikely group together and watches the chaos unfold, Dirk Gently operates on a similar principle, just cranked much further into the surreal. The partnership between Dirk and Todd has that same friction-and-affection quality, and the show has a real sense of comedic timing. It's stranger and more science-fiction adjacent, but the core pleasure of watching mismatched people stumble toward the truth together is identical.
Stream on AMC Plus Apple TV Channel , AMC+ Amazon Channel, AMC+ Roku Premium Channel, AMC+
Cancelled0%
3. Santa Clarita Diet
Santa Clarita Diet shares Only Murders' willingness to play a murder absolutely straight while also being very, very funny. The central partnership here is a married couple rather than three neighbors, but the dynamic of two people trying to manage a crime situation while keeping their lives intact will feel familiar. It leans harder into horror-comedy than mystery, but the offbeat tone and the affection between its leads make it an easy watch for fans of the show.
Stream on Netflix
Cancelled0%
4. Deadloch
Deadloch gives you two leads with sharply different personalities forced to work together on a murder in a small, insular community, which is practically the core DNA of Only Murders transplanted to coastal Australia. The comedy is pointed and the mystery is taken seriously enough to pay off. Fans who appreciated the way Only Murders uses its setting as both backdrop and subject will find Deadloch doing the same thing with its sleepy seaside town.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Likely Renewed62%
5. The Resort
Also comedy · shares the murder mystery theme
Stream on Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Ended0%
More on shows like Only Murders in the Building
Fans of this show tend to be looking for a few specific things. They want a mystery that actually respects them as viewers, clues and red herrings that feel fair rather than arbitrary. They want humor that doesn't undercut the tension. And they want characters they'd happily spend time with even if there were no crime to solve at all. The whodunit mechanics matter, but personality matters more.
The shows here satisfy those cravings in different ways. Poker Face scratches the procedural itch with a fresh case every episode, built around a protagonist with a genuinely interesting premise. Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency shares that same slightly chaotic, unlikely-duo energy, pushed further into the absurd. The Afterparty is the most structurally inventive of the bunch, doing something smart with the genre-per-suspect format. Deadloch brings two mismatched leads, real comedic friction, and a murder in an unlikely setting. Santa Clarita Diet is the furthest from a traditional mystery, but fans who appreciate the show's dark comedy streak and its portrait of an oddly functional partnership will find something familiar there.
None of these are perfect replicas of Only Murders, and the best ones aren't trying to be. Poker Face has a lonelier, more melancholy tone. Deadloch has a sharper satirical edge. The Afterparty is almost more interested in storytelling form than in the crime itself. But all of them understand the same basic thing: a mystery is only as good as the people at the center of it.
More shows like Only Murders in the Building
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Only Murders in the Building?
- Poker Face is the most popular show similar to Only Murders in the Building in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Only Murders in the Building still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to Only Murders in the Building listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Only Murders in the Building?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.