TV Shows Like Fargo
If you like Fargo, here are 11 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
FX · Crime · Fargo is likely renewed
Fargo works because it refuses to play it straight. Every season drops a new set of characters into the frozen upper Midwest, and the show finds real menace and dark absurdity in equal measure. The violence is sudden and consequential, but it sits alongside moments of deadpan bewilderment, small-town politeness, and characters who are either catastrophically evil or stubbornly decent, with very little in between. That tonal balance is hard to pull off, and Fargo does it consistently across its anthology seasons.
The best shows like Fargo
1. Grimm
Grimm is a different kind of show from Fargo, adding a supernatural and fairy-tale layer to its Portland detective premise, but the core tension between a detective's professional instincts and a stranger, darker world maps onto what Fargo does with its ordinary characters in extraordinary situations. The neo-noir atmosphere is solid, and the show enjoys the same kind of deadpan disbelief that Fargo gets so much mileage out of. It is less grim in tone but more inventive in premise.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Peacock Premium, Amazon Prime Video with Ads, Peacock Premium Plus
Ended0%
2. True Detective
True Detective is the most natural next step for a Fargo fan. It shares the anthology structure, the neo-noir atmosphere, and a deep interest in what crime does to the people who investigate it. Each season has a distinct identity, and the show is serious about mood and place in a way that Fargo viewers will recognize immediately.
Stream on HBO Max Amazon Channel, YouTube TV, TNT, HBO Max
Likely Renewed72%
3. 21 Jump Street
21 Jump Street is the lightest entry on this list, and Fargo fans should go in knowing the tone is considerably brighter. That said, the premise of cops operating outside their normal context, using disguise and wit rather than authority, has an underdog quality that echoes some of Fargo's more resourceful deputies. It is a solid procedural with enough character to keep it from feeling routine.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, Peacock Premium, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Ended0%
4. The Sinner
The Sinner centers on a detective who is as psychologically troubled as the cases he takes on, which gives it the same inside-out quality that makes Fargo's lawmen so interesting. The crimes here are not whodunits so much as explorations of why, and the show digs into memory, guilt, and compulsion with real patience. If you liked Fargo's quieter, more unsettling moments, this one will get under your skin.
Stream on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Ended0%
5. American Crime Story
American Crime Story takes actual criminal investigations and rebuilds them with the kind of character detail that Fargo fans appreciate in fictional crime. It is more procedural and less absurdist than Fargo, but the anthology format and the moral seriousness with which it treats its subjects make it a comfortable fit. Each season is essentially a self-contained story about how institutions and individuals respond to spectacular crimes.
Stream on Hulu
Ended0%
More on shows like Fargo
Fans of Fargo tend to want a few specific things from their next show. First, moral weight. They want crimes that feel like they actually matter, not procedural puzzles that reset every week. Second, atmosphere. Fargo is as much about place and mood as it is about plot, and its viewers notice when a show has a real sense of where it is. Third, they tend to appreciate characters who are a little off-center, people who think differently, whether that means a detective processing grief through casework or a criminal whose logic is perfectly consistent and completely alien. The anthology format is also a draw for a lot of Fargo viewers, since it lets a show reinvent itself while staying true to a sensibility.
The recommendations here cover a decent range. True Detective is the most direct match, sharing the anthology structure, the neo-noir mood, and a willingness to sit inside a detective's psychology for long stretches. The Sinner takes a similar interest in damaged investigators and inexplicable crimes, though it leans harder into psychological mystery. American Crime Story goes after real events with a procedural rigor that Fargo-style fans will respect, even if the tone is more earnest. Grimm is lighter and more genre-fantastical, but the detective-at-odds-with-a-strange-world premise has real appeal. And 21 Jump Street is the outlier in mood, brighter and more rooted in procedural tradition, though the undercover premise gives it enough edge to satisfy.
None of these are Fargo, and they shouldn't try to be. What they share with it is a commitment to character inside crime, the sense that how people respond to violence says something true about them. That's what keeps Fargo viewers coming back, and it's the thread running through all five of these shows.
More shows like Fargo
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Fargo?
- Grimm is the most popular show similar to Fargo in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Fargo still on the air?
- Of the 11 shows similar to Fargo listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Fargo?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.