TV Shows Like All Her Fault
If you like All Her Fault, here are 9 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
Sky Atlantic · Mystery · All Her Fault is ended
All Her Fault delivers the thing that gets under a parent's skin most effectively: the sudden, unexplained disappearance of a child. Marissa Irvine's walk to Arthur Avenue should be routine, unremarkable, the kind of errand that happens a thousand times a day in any city. Instead it becomes the pivot point between ordinary life and catastrophe. What makes this mystery so effective is that we're not watching a detective puzzle things out from a distance. We're watching a mother descend into the abyss of not knowing where her son is, and that personal horror anchors everything that follows.
The best shows like All Her Fault
1. Agatha Christie's Poirot
If you're drawn to mysteries where the solution feels inevitable once you see the pieces correctly arranged, Poirot offers exactly that satisfaction. His cases often involve missing persons, hidden motives, and the kind of careful observation that turns seemingly innocent details into evidence of wrongdoing.
Stream on Hulu, Britbox Apple TV Channel , PBS, BritBox
Ended0%
2. Perry Mason
Perry Mason shares All Her Fault's interest in how crimes upend lives and the legal fight to set things right. The show is built around cases where the innocent need defending and where the investigative work has to be thorough enough to prove it.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, YouTube TV, Philo
Ended0%
3. High Potential
Morgan's approach to solving crimes mirrors the urgency you feel watching Marissa search for Milo. She's a mother first and an investigator second, which means every case carries emotional weight alongside the intellectual puzzle of who did what and why.
Stream on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
Likely Renewed92%
4. Agatha Christie's Marple
Miss Marple solves crimes by understanding human nature and recognizing patterns others miss. Like All Her Fault, her investigations often begin when normal life is disrupted by something terrible, and she brings a sharp, practical eye to unraveling what happened.
Stream on Hulu, Britbox Apple TV Channel , PBS, Acorn TV
Ended0%
5. Private Eyes
Private Eyes understands that real investigative work is gritty and collaborative, requiring both sharp instincts and relentless follow-through. The partnership between Shade and Everett mirrors the kind of teamwork needed to untangle the kind of crime that could destroy a family.
Stream on fuboTV, Philo, Hallmark+ Amazon Channel, Hallmark+ Apple TV Channel
Cancelled0%
More on shows like All Her Fault
Fans of All Her Fault are drawn to mysteries that feel lived-in and urgent rather than academic. They want crime stories where the stakes feel real because we understand exactly what's being lost. They're watching to see not just who took the child or why, but how people behave when normal rules no longer apply, when the only thing that matters is getting back what's been taken. The mystery works because we're invested in the outcome before we even know there's a puzzle to solve.
The shows we've lined up here all share that investigative spine, though they approach it from different angles. Agatha Christie's Poirot and Agatha Christie's Marple are the classics of the form, where the pleasure comes from watching brilliant minds untangle deception and wrongdoing. Perry Mason and Private Eyes lean into the idea that solving crimes is work, often unglamorous work, and that the people doing it have to be as clever and resourceful as the people they're chasing. High Potential takes the core idea of an unconventional investigator and makes it personal: Morgan uses her exceptional mind to solve crimes while juggling single motherhood, adding another layer of tension to every case. Each of these shows understands that what keeps us watching is not just the mystery itself, but the people doing the investigating and what the case costs them.
More shows like All Her Fault
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like All Her Fault?
- Agatha Christie's Poirot is the most popular show similar to All Her Fault in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like All Her Fault still on the air?
- Of the 9 shows similar to All Her Fault listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like All Her Fault?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.