TV Shows Like The Vampire Diaries
If you like The Vampire Diaries, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
The CW · Drama · The Vampire Diaries is ended
The Vampire Diaries ran on a very specific kind of tension: two brothers in love with the same woman, a mythology that kept expanding to swallow whole new species and eras, and a pace that rarely let you breathe between revelations. What made it stick, beyond the obvious romantic hooks, was its willingness to treat its supernatural world seriously. Vampires had rules, witches had consequences, and the past kept crashing into the present in the form of doppelgangers and century-old grudges. The show also had an earnestness that its more cynical competitors lacked. It believed in eternal love, and it made you believe in it too, at least for forty-two minutes at a time.
The best shows like The Vampire Diaries
1. Supernatural
Supernatural shares the same DNA of American gothic monster-hunting, with demons, witches, angels, and things considerably worse all showing up across its long run. The brotherly relationship at its core is as emotionally loaded as any romance on The Vampire Diaries, and the show builds a mythology that keeps complicating itself in ways that feel earned rather than arbitrary. It runs long, which is either a warning or a promise depending on how attached you get to characters.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Peacock Premium, TNT, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Ended0%
2. True Blood
True Blood is set in a world where vampires have recently gone public, which gives it a political and social texture that The Vampire Diaries mostly avoided, but the romantic entanglement between humans and vampires is just as central. It's considerably more explicit and darkly comic in tone, but the pull of dangerous, centuries-old creatures and the humans drawn to them is exactly the same. Fans who liked the vampire mythology and the steamy interspecies romance will feel right at home.
Stream on Hulu, HBO Max Amazon Channel, YouTube TV, HBO Max
Ended0%
3. Lost Girl
Lost Girl puts a supernatural creature at the center rather than the edges, following a succubus who refuses to pick a side in a war between supernatural factions while also navigating a love triangle with real romantic weight. The show has the same mix of urban fantasy world-building and emotional investment in its characters' relationships that made The Vampire Diaries work. If the female characters and their agency were what you responded to most, Bo is a protagonist worth following.
Ended0%
4. Mayfair Witches
Mayfair Witches follows a young woman who discovers she's the heir to a powerful witch family, complete with a sinister presence that has shadowed her bloodline for generations, which should feel very familiar to anyone who watched the Bennett witch storylines in The Vampire Diaries. The show is based on source novels with the same kind of dense, gothic mythology that Anne Rice fans and TVD fans tend to overlap on. It's slower-paced than The Vampire Diaries, but the weight of inherited supernatural legacy is very much the same.
Stream on Netflix, Philo, AMC Plus Apple TV Channel , AMC+ Amazon Channel
Likely Cancelled25%
5. The Hunger
The Hunger is an anthology, so it doesn't offer the ongoing character relationships that define The Vampire Diaries, but each episode digs into themes of obsession, desire, and the supernatural in ways that fans of darker vampire fiction will recognize. It's more interested in mood and dread than romance, and its episodic format means you can dip in without committing to a long arc. Worth it for viewers who want something stranger and more explicitly horror-flavored.
Ended0%
More on shows like The Vampire Diaries
Fans of the show tend to want a few specific things when they go looking for something new. They want a supernatural world with real stakes and internal logic, not just monsters as window dressing. They want romantic tension that actually hurts, ideally complicated by someone being literally dangerous to someone else. And they tend to respond to shows that aren't afraid to be a little over-the-top, as long as the emotional core stays honest. A slow, naturalistic drama is probably not going to scratch the same itch.
The recommendations here cover a fairly wide range of that territory. Supernatural is the closest in tone if you swap romance for brotherhood, and it runs deep enough to lose yourself in for a long time. True Blood is the most adult version of the vampire-romance world, with more explicit content and sharper political edges. Lost Girl splits the difference, keeping the love triangle and interspecies romance but centering a female protagonist with her own mythology to unravel. Mayfair Witches leans into the witch side of things, with a brooding generational curse that should feel familiar to anyone who spent time with Bonnie Bennett's storylines. The Hunger is the outlier, an anthology series rather than a serialized drama, and its episodic structure means you won't get the ongoing character investment the others offer. It's worth knowing going in that it's more of a horror mood piece than a narrative.
None of these are exact replacements, and none of them should be. The best thing a recommendation can do is find the part of the original show that mattered most to you and follow that thread somewhere new. If it was the vampire lore, start with True Blood. If it was the supernatural world-building and found family, go to Supernatural. If it was the romantic entanglement with a dangerous creature at its center, Lost Girl is the closest match. Mayfair Witches is the right call if the witch mythology was what kept you watching.
More shows like The Vampire Diaries
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like The Vampire Diaries?
- Supernatural is the most popular show similar to The Vampire Diaries in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like The Vampire Diaries still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to The Vampire Diaries listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like The Vampire Diaries?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.