TV Shows Like Supernatural
If you like Supernatural, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
The WB · Drama · Supernatural is ended
Supernatural ran for fifteen seasons, which is a long time to spend on a single road trip, and it earned every one of them. The core of the show is straightforward: two brothers drive across America killing things that go bump in the night. But what kept audiences around was never really the monsters. It was Sam and Dean, the way they argue and sacrifice and drag each other back from the edge, season after season. The mythology gets enormous over time, stretching from ghost-of-the-week proceduralism to full-blown apocalyptic warfare with angels and demons, and the show wears that ambition with varying degrees of grace. The early seasons are lean and scary. The later ones are sprawling and operatic. Fans tend to love both.
The best shows like Supernatural
1. The Vampire Diaries
Like Supernatural, The Vampire Diaries takes its monster mythology seriously and builds a complicated, layered world around it. The central relationship here is a love triangle rather than a brotherly bond, but the emotional weight and the willingness to put main characters in genuine peril will feel familiar. If you liked Supernatural's treatment of vampires and witches as part of a larger supernatural ecosystem with its own history and rules, this show does something similar.
Stream on HBO Max Amazon Channel, Peacock Premium, YouTube TV, HBO Max
Ended0%
2. American Horror Story
American Horror Story shares Supernatural's appetite for witches, demons, cults, and apocalyptic scenarios, and it goes after them with real nastiness. The anthology format means each season is its own contained story, so it scratches the same itch as Supernatural's early monster-of-the-week episodes but with a feature-film-level commitment to atmosphere and dread. Fans who loved the show's darker, scarier stretches will find a lot to enjoy here, even if the emotional core is more diffuse.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Disney Plus, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Likely Renewed97%
3. Shadowhunters
Shadowhunters is built around a team of demon hunters operating in a world full of vampires, werewolves, and warlocks, which puts it in very familiar territory for Supernatural fans. The tone is a bit younger and the lore comes from a specific book series, but the pleasure of watching people who are good at fighting evil actually fight evil is the same. The ensemble dynamic and the ongoing mythology give it the kind of serialized momentum that made Supernatural easy to binge.
Stream on Hulu
Ended0%
5. The Hunger
The Hunger is an older anthology series with a dark, erotic edge and a taste for vampires, ghosts, and obsession. Each episode is self-contained, which makes it closer to Supernatural's standalone episodes than to its season-long story arcs. Fans who enjoyed the show's grimier, more atmospheric early hours and don't mind slower, more literary genre storytelling will find this one worth exploring.
Ended0%
More on shows like Supernatural
What those fans are usually looking for in their next show is some combination of the following: a strong central relationship holding together a supernatural premise, monsters treated with genuine menace rather than camp, a world that has its own internal rules and lore, and at least a trace of dark humor. They tend to tolerate, even enjoy, shows that take big swings and sometimes miss, as long as the emotional stakes feel real. Pure horror is not always the goal; neither is pure romance. The sweet spot is somewhere in the middle, where the supernatural threat is the pressure that forces characters to reveal who they actually are.
The recommendations here cover that range. The Vampire Diaries and Shadowhunters both put supernatural creatures at the center of ongoing serialized drama with strong ensemble casts. American Horror Story goes in a different direction entirely, leaning into pure horror anthology territory but touching on several of Supernatural's favorite subjects, including witches, demons, and apocalyptic scenarios. The Hunger and Masters of Horror are older, anthology-format shows that share Supernatural's taste for dark, self-contained genre storytelling, even if they lack its emotional throughline.
None of these shows are Supernatural, and they shouldn't try to be. What they share with it is a seriousness about the genre. They treat the supernatural as a lens for examining real fears, real grief, and real relationships. That is what Supernatural did at its best, and it is a reasonable thing to go looking for next.
More shows like Supernatural
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Supernatural?
- The Vampire Diaries is the most popular show similar to Supernatural in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Supernatural still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to Supernatural listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Supernatural?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.