TV Shows Like Supernatural
If you like Supernatural, here are 12 similar TV shows — each with its current AI renewal verdict, so you can see which are still going and which have been cancelled.
The WB · Drama · Supernatural is ended
Supernatural ran for fifteen seasons, which tells you something about how well it understood its audience. At its core, it is a road show about two brothers who happen to kill monsters for a living, and that combination, grief-soaked family drama wrapped inside genre horror, is what kept people coming back long after the mythology grew unwieldy. Sam and Dean Winchester are genuinely fun to spend time with. The show earns its loneliness and its humor in equal measure, and the Impala rolling down an empty American highway at night became one of the more honest images on network television.
The best shows like Supernatural
1. The Vampire Diaries
Like Supernatural, The Vampire Diaries puts family and loyalty at the center of its supernatural world, with two brothers whose complicated bond drives the story as much as any monster does. The small-town setting and deep vampire lore will feel familiar, and the show builds a mythology that rewards long-term viewers. It is warmer and more romance-focused than Supernatural, but the emotional stakes hit the same notes.
Stream on HBO Max, HBO Max Amazon Channel, Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Ended0%
2. American Horror Story
American Horror Story shares Supernatural's appetite for horror mythology and its willingness to go to genuinely dark places, covering haunted houses, witch covens, apocalyptic scenarios and more across its anthology format. Fans who loved when Supernatural dug into specific horror archetypes, witches, demons, the end of the world, will find a lot to enjoy here. The tone is grimmer and more explicit, but the ambition to cover as much of the horror map as possible is the same.
Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Disney Plus, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Likely Renewed95%
3. Masters of Horror
Masters of Horror is an anthology series made by the people who defined the genre, and if part of what drew you to Supernatural was its respect for horror tradition, this is a logical next stop. Each episode is its own contained story, which suits the format well. It is not interested in long-running character arcs, but for pure horror craft it is hard to beat.
Ended0%
4. Shadowhunters
Shadowhunters is the most direct match for Supernatural's demon-hunting premise, following a protagonist who discovers she is part of a secret world dedicated to killing demons and protecting humanity. The show leans into its mythology and builds out a large ensemble of hunters, warlocks, vampires and werewolves who all have complicated histories with each other. Fans who liked the sense of a hidden world running parallel to the ordinary one will feel at home here.
Stream on Hulu
Ended0%
5. American Horror Stories
American Horror Stories takes the anthology approach of its parent series and distills it into self-contained episodes, each pulling from horror myths, legends and folklore. For Supernatural fans who loved the standalone monster-of-the-week episodes as much as the larger arc, this format scratches a similar itch. It is efficient and varied, and does not ask for a huge time commitment to get a satisfying horror story.
Stream on Hulu
Ended0%
More on shows like Supernatural
Fans of Supernatural tend to want a few specific things from their next show: the supernatural (obviously), a sense of stakes that feels personal rather than abstract, characters whose relationships matter as much as the monsters, and a willingness to go dark without losing the thread of hope. They are not necessarily looking for prestige-drama restraint. They want mythology, lore, and the occasional moment where someone makes a deal with a demon and regrets it immediately.
The recommendations here cover a good range of that territory. The Vampire Diaries shares the family-anchored emotional core and the small-town supernatural atmosphere, while Shadowhunters picks up the demon-hunting mission almost directly, following a young woman who discovers she belongs to a secret world of hunters protecting humanity from demonic forces. American Horror Story and its spin-off American Horror Stories both lean into anthology horror with the kind of ambition and excess that Supernatural fans tend to appreciate, even if the tone is darker and less warm. Masters of Horror is the oldest entry on the list and the most stripped-down, but for fans who came to Supernatural partly for its horror pedigree, it is worth knowing the genre's roots.
None of these shows are Supernatural, and none of them try to be, which is probably the right call. What they share with it is a comfort with the strange and the monstrous, and a belief that horror works best when it is attached to something human.
More shows like Supernatural
Frequently asked
- What is the most popular show like Supernatural?
- The Vampire Diaries is the most popular show similar to Supernatural in the IsItRenewed catalogue.
- Are shows like Supernatural still on the air?
- Of the 12 shows similar to Supernatural listed here, 0 currently carry a renewed verdict — the rest are cancelled, ended, or awaiting a decision.
- How does IsItRenewed pick shows like Supernatural?
- The recommendations come from TMDB's similar-titles data, and each is shown with its current AI renewal verdict so you know which are still going.