Full cast of Tell Me a Story

Paul Wesley

Tucker Reed / Eddie Longo

20 episodes

Danielle Campbell

Olivia Moon / Kayla Powell

20 episodes

James Wolk

Jordan Evans

10 episodes

Billy Magnussen

Nick Sullivan

10 episodes

Dania Ramirez

Hannah Perez

10 episodes

Dorian Missick

Sam Reynolds

10 episodes

Michael Raymond-James

Mitch Longo

10 episodes

Davi Santos

Gabe Perez

10 episodes

Sam Jaeger

Tim Powell

10 episodes

Zabryna Guevara

Renee Garcia

10 episodes

Kim Cattrall

Colleen Powell

10 episodes

Eka Darville

Beau Morris

10 episodes

Carrie-Anne Moss

Rebecca Pruitt

10 episodes

Ashley Madekwe

Simone Garland

10 episodes

Matt Lauria

Jackson Pruitt

10 episodes

Odette Annable

Maddie Pruitt

10 episodes

Natalie Alyn Lind

Ashley Rose Pruitt

10 episodes

Paulina Singer

Laney Reed

8 episodes

Becki Newton

Katrina Thorn

7 episodes

Kurt Yaeger

Terry

7 episodes

Spencer Grammer

Beth

6 episodes

Rarmian Newton

Ethan Davies

5 episodes

Justine Cotsonas

Carla

4 episodes

Tonya Glanz

Shelley Longo

4 episodes

Debra Monk

Esther Thorn

4 episodes

James Martinez

Detective Olsen

4 episodes

Harry Shum Jr.

Brendan

4 episodes

Kathryn Prescott

Susie

4 episodes

Luke Guldan

Billy

3 episodes

Jennifer Ikeda

Rita

3 episodes

Sydney James Harcourt

Lance

3 episodes

Sanjit De Silva

Mark

3 episodes

Dan Amboyer

Harry

3 episodes

Polly Draper

Madeline Winston

3 episodes

Tom Lipinski

Bruce

3 episodes

David Andrews

Richard Winston

2 episodes

Elliot Villar

Detective Herrera

2 episodes

Quincy Chad

Detective Grant

2 episodes

Simone Missick

Marianna Reynolds

2 episodes

Paul Rolfes

Dan Simmons

1 episode

Marguerite Moreau

Abby Powell

1 episode

Amanda Jaros

Christine

1 episode

Lynn Marocola

NYPD Officer (uncredited)

1 episode

Stacy-Ann Gooden

Newscaster #1

1 episode

Kendall Lloyd

Redneck

1 episode

J. J. Soria

Wade

1 episode

Emily Borromeo

Jennifer

1 episode